For most of us the key to the great commercial or ad or marketing idea or message lies within something that is already true about what we do. We just need the eyes to see it and the guts to go for it.

-Gabe the Bass Player


Finished reading: The Weirdstone of Brisingamen by Alan Garner 📚


😬

last year, the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) published a two-part report finding that 15% of programmatic, open-web advertising dollars went to MFA websites, totaling about $10 billion in ad spend.

A new report found

H&R Block served more than 2,100 impressions to one user on an MFA site within an hour.

Comcast paid an effective CPM of $2,628 to reach one consumer on an MFA site.

an ad-spend analysis on behalf of a Fortune 500 company and found that in the second half of 2023, it had spent at least $10 million on MFA websites

MFA is made-for-advertising aka junk

via Marketing Brew


Today a client said “it doesn’t matter what we think, let’s try stuff out and see what works.”

Music to my ears.

Defer to data.


The Nudge podcast covered irrational prices, noting they essentially act as a hook cementing your brand in people’s minds (Costco’s $1.50 hot dog, Ryanair’s charging for everything, Supreme’s drop strategy, etc).

The gem is the bit at the end about loyalty programs.

[Pret A Manger] staff have a certain number of items or dollar amount they have to give away every week.

Random rewards.

Slot machine psychology meets unexpected moments of delight meets empowered employees meets positive emotions all around.

An equation for sharing.

A super cost effective marketing campaign.


What the birth of the spreadsheet teaches us about generative AI

There is one very clear parallel between the digital spreadsheet and generative AI: both are computer apps that collapse time. A task that might have taken hours or days can suddenly be completed in seconds

But

When a tool is ubiquitous, and convenient, we kludge our way through without really understanding what the tool is doing or why. And that, as a parallel for generative AI, is alarmingly on the nose.


Not great Bob!

Advertising still largely fails to adequately represent women with intersectional identities, either relying on stereotypes or failing to include them entirely

On the positive side

more women in ads are breaking free from their traditional placements in family and domestic settings, dropping from 66% of portrayals in 2022 to 30% in 2023.

Your customers should see themselves reflected in your brand and its ads.

via Campaign


Are the algorithms starting to turn on generative AI?

Google has updated Search to derank spam including:

  • Scaled content abuse (aka made by AI)
  • Site reputation abuse (junk third-party content on quality sites)
  • Expired domain abuse (grabbing an expired domain and starting a spam farm)

The goal is to:

better understand if webpages are unhelpful, have a poor user experience or feel like they were created for search engines instead of people. This could include sites created primarily to match very specific search queries.

This change actually has teeth too, with plenty of manual actions.


How To Connect To Your Clients' Meta Account

One of the most annoying things we have to deal with on a (fairly) regular basis with Blue Ion clients is getting access to various Meta properties and tools so we can manage their advertising.

This isn’t because of the clients, it’s because of Meta. It’s pretty much always a headache and 3x more clicks than you would think necessary.

Before I outline the process we’ve landed on lately (for now?), a few ground rules we play by:

  • This assumes the client already has a Meta Business Manager setup and they can access it (this can be a big assumption). If one doesn’t exist we’ll help create one for/with them.
  • We believe that these accounts belong to the client and if they choose to move away from us as an agency, they should easily be able to take the accounts with them. We are working on their behalf, they aren’t renting their advertising from us.
  • We set it up so the clients are billed direct by Meta, we don’t charge passthrough markups or CPC fees (see above point).

Now, on to the access!

We’ve found the easiest method is having the client add us to their Business Manager as a partner (official documentation here).

We grab our business ID from the main business settings URL for our agency Business Manager. This is the most reliable way I’ve found to get it in an easy copy-paste format.

We then share that with the client along with the documentation link.

They then access their Business Manager settings, navigate to Partners in the left menu, click the blue “Add” button, and “Give a partner access to your assets.”

The assets that need to be shared may change on a case-by-case basis, but we ask for:

  • Facebook Page
  • Instagram account
  • Ad Account
  • Pixel / Dataset

The ideal is to get manage access for all assets, but we just request the highest level they’re comfortable granting us.

Then we wait for them to appear in our Partners list and assign out asset access as needed.

Voilà! Happy advertising!

& stay curious


It feels like the “new normal” we were promised / warned about during the height of the pandemic is starting to settle in, and it’s basically a more conservative (not in the political sense) version of the time leading up to Covid.

Three years ago, the U.S. economy went through an unprecedented upheaval…

It was called the “great resignation.”

Fast-forward to today, and the situation looks like a mirror image, economists say. Specifically, on average, few workers are leaving their jobs, though they still do not face the prospect of imminent layoffs.

via NBC News